Guest post: What "Any Qualified Provider" means for the NHS

Posted on Mon 3rd Oct 2011, 3:34pm
This is a guest post by Richard Blogger. He runs the website http://nhsvault.blogspot.com and also writes for False Economy.



In Conservative, Liberal Democrat and Blairite circles there has always been an opinion of "why does it matter who owns the hospital, as long as the care is free". It does matter. It matters because a publicly owned hospital and a publicly owned community health service are part of the community and they have a responsibility for the community. This commitment to the community means that there is a continuity of care: patients know that their NHS hospital, their GP, their district nurse will always be there for them.

The government knows that they cannot put up "For Sale" signs on hospitals and clinics around the country; they know that if they did this, MPs of the two parties in the Coalition would be ousted at the next election. Instead, the Conservative part of the government have produced a far more cunning plan. It is called Any Qualified Provider, and it will fragment the NHS through the use of many different private companies. These companies will mostly be for-profit, although some will be not-for-profit. None of these companies will have the long term commitment to the community that the NHS has. Private for-profit companies are driven by the need for short-term profit making rather than a long term commitment to patient care.

Under AQP when a patient's GP recommends treatment they will give the patient the "choice" of any healthcare provider from a list of registered "qualified providers". The patient will not be told who owns the provider or whether the provider is for-profit or not-for-profit. The government will even allow private providers to use the NHS logo, so patients may think they are using the NHS when they are not. The new for-profit and voluntary sector providers will not be subject to the same regulations of transparency and accountability that NHS providers have to follow. This will mean that patients who use these new providers will not be able to question their business practices.

The government says that "patient choice" is at the centre of the new NHS they are creating. The choice that a patient makes will determine the future of their local hospital and it will determine the availability of specialist and expensive care at NHS hospitals. When a patient chooses a non-NHS provider it means that the money that pays for their care will go to the alternative provider (and potentially some of it will end up as a profit paid to shareholders as a dividend). The result will be that the income of NHS providers – hospitals and community health services – will be cut.

About half of the work that hospitals do is paid using a fixed pricelist called tariff that is determined by the Department of Health. In practice, some treatments will cost a hospital less than tariff to provide and so the hospital makes a surplus, but the hospital may also provide a treatment that costs more than tariff and this creates a deficit. Hospital managers work hard to make the surpluses equal or exceed the deficits and this cross-subsidy is important because without it deficit-making services provided as a social benefit for the community will close. For-profit companies are more likely to perform treatments that generate surpluses: they need to do this to make a profit. When a patient has their treatment by such a non-NHS provider, it threatens the viability of the deficit-generating services at the NHS hospital they would have used, and ultimately the hospital may have to stop providing the service and the community will be deprived of that service. A patient's choice for a simple procedure may affect many other patients who depend upon a difficult, expensive service.

Private and voluntary sector providers do not suffer this issue because as Any Qualified Providers they can choose the services they provide: and that will inevitably mean they will choose services that are cheap and easy to provide and will send patients with complicated conditions back to the NHS. Private and voluntary sector providers do not provide emergency treatment: A&E, intensive care units and the skills that the staff need to treat emergencies are costly and these are costs that the private and voluntary sector do not have to bear.

The privatisation of the NHS will not occur as the sale of an NHS hospital trust; instead it will occur when departments within a hospital close because there are not enough patients to cover costs. The government is encouraging this situation by cutting the income of hospitals. David Cameron said that he would not cut the NHS, yet in April this year the government cut tariff by 1.5%, which means that hospital incomes have been cut. Some hospitals will attempt to generate more income by taking on private patients. This will be self-defeating, since it will create a two-tier system where NHS patients will be second in the queue to private patients. NHS patients, fed up with a second rate service compared to private patients will inevitably use their "patient choice" to use another hospital, most likely a private one. The privatisation planned by the government will be gradual, but irreversible.

The Health and Social Care Bill provides the legal framework for this privatisation by creating the unelected NHS Commissioning Board, so that our elected representatives will not be able to halt privatisations. The Bill will also turning Monitor into an economic regulator (with a mandate to "prevent anti-competitive behaviour", ie promote competition) who will force privatisations through.

We must do everything we can do defeat the Bill and prevent these privatisations. But in the unpalatable situation of the Bill being passed, there is a simple message here. If you value the specialist services that your local NHS hospital provides then you should choose to have all of your treatment at that NHS hospital since any treatment you have at an Any Qualified Provider will put at risk the NHS hospital. Our NHS: Choose it, or lose it.

Join Richard and over 2000 others on Sunday as we Block the Bridge, Block the Bill

Block the Bridge, Block the Bill legal tips

Posted on Mon 3rd Oct 2011, 10:40am
To those first time activists who may feel a little nervous… here is some advice.

First of all, you are in good company. Many people have had their first experiences of direct action and civil disobedience with UK Uncut, and had a great time. You only need to have a look through the photos and videos in our gallery to see what our actions are like. There haven’t been many instances of arrests at UK Uncut actions. But, as we have learned, it is still impossible to predict the police’s reaction. So it’s best to be prepared.

The fantastic Green and Black Cross legal support group will have teams of legal observers there on the day checking police behaviour and will run an offsite legal support line. Here are a couple of things you can do:
  • Take a look at this advice card, and keep one in your pocket on the day of the action. Use the recommended solicitor and support numbers provided if necessary.
  • Bring a friend with you. Make an agreement to look out for each other throughout the day. Go up and chat to people already there too!
You may also want to have a look through the legal briefings produced by the Activists' Legal Project and Green and Black Cross. You can get in touch with legal@ukuncut.org.uk with any further questions.

Now that you’re prepared, we’ll see you on the bridge!

Green and Black Cross are running a fantastic free training event this Saturday for people wanting to learn how to act as a legal observer

Raise £1000 for the Brighton 9

Posted on Tue 27th Sep 2011, 11:28am


On 4th December last year, members of Brighton Uncut glued themselves to the inside of a window at Topshop in one of the most audacious and widely read about actions to date. They were using the example of Topshop boss Philip Green's £285m tax dodge to highlight the now well-publicised link between tax avoidance and public spending cuts.

Friday saw the culmination of their two-week trial, which featured Caroline Lucas MP, tax expert Richard Murphy and Dr Ron Singer called as expert witnesses by the defence. Caroline Lucas offered her full support to the Brighton 9, who she says "put the ethics back into politics".

In a front page story, the local paper branded the £100,000 trial a "waste of money" and noted that defendants were actually cleared of most charges. Nevertheless, five were found guilty of accidentally damaging two mannequins which toppled over when they entered the window display and handed £200 fines each.

In a show of solidarity, and encouragement for those planning on taking action in the future, we're attempting to cover the £1000.

You can donate via bank transfer (drop us an email to donations@ukuncut.org.uk afterwards with your donation amount) or Paypal. We'll update this page with details of how the fundraising is going!

Update 28/09 10am: We raised £80 in the first day. Just 92 more people donating £10 each would cover the whole amount!

Update 28/09 11am: We're now over a third of the way through!

Update 28/09 1pm: We've now raised over £500! Keep going for the superglue stars.

Update 29/09 11am: £830, we're almost there! 17 more people donating £10 each would cover the entire amount.

Update 29/09 12pm: WE MADE IT! What an inspiring show of solidarity! We'll have a guest blog from Brighton Uncut up soon!

Brighton Uncut will be helping to Block the Bridge, Block the Bill on 9th October!
Displaying posts 178 - 180 of 279 in total

Latest posts

Guest blog: Day of Action for our Railways
Fri 15th Aug 2014, 8:44am
CALL OUT: #VodafoneAGM: Occupy Online
Mon 28th Jul 2014, 12:00pm
Guest blog: Tax Dodging Tours
Thu 24th Jul 2014, 1:22pm
Guest blog: Hands off our Public Services! Take Action Against TTIP, 12 July.
Tue 1st Jul 2014, 2:24pm
Guest blog: why I support the occupation of Westminster Abbey
Sat 28th Jun 2014, 4:47pm
CALL OUT: Boot Out Boots
Tue 24th Jun 2014, 1:06pm
Know Your Rights
Mon 23rd Jun 2014, 1:17pm
CALL OUT: Tax Dodgers Alliance
Tue 17th Jun 2014, 8:00am
Guest blog: a Small Spark of Hope
Sun 15th Jun 2014, 6:30pm
Press release: 12 actions across the UK
Sat 14th Jun 2014, 9:00pm
Displaying posts 1 - 10 of 279 in total