Introducing UK Uncut Legal Action

Posted on Fri 28th Oct 2011, 10:46am
This is a guest blog post from UK Uncut Legal Action. Follow them on Twitter and Facebook and check out their website



When activists start talking about court cases, evidence, expert witnesses and meetings with lawyers, it generally means that either they or their friends will be going through a tough and stressful time. Too often it is those people willing to stick their necks out to fight injustice that are dragged through the courts. But not always. Criminal damage to us doesn’t always mean supergluing yourself to Topshop, we believe it is criminal for public servants to act unlawfully, especially when these acts reflect a greed and self-interest that damage us all.

UK Uncut Legal Action is a new, spin-off project, separate to- but inspired by- UK Uncut and their fight for an alternative to the cuts. UK Uncut have shown that the cuts are a political choice, not an economic necessity and that this choice is driven by the interests of big business, the finance sector and wealthy individuals, not caring for people.

Today, UK Uncut Legal Action has announced that it is threatening a legal challenge in the High Court over HMRC’s ‘sweetheart’ tax deal with the investment bank giant, Goldman Sachs. The crux of the matter appears to be that back in the 1990s, Goldman Sachs didn’t want people to know just how much money their bankers were being paid, and they allegedly didn’t fancy paying all of their National Insurance contributions. Reportedly, they set up a new company in the British Virgin Islands, and bought into a scheme called Employment Beneficiary Trusts. It wasn’t until 2005, after much legal wrangling, the courts declared that these Trusts were tax avoiding schemes, and it was time to pay back £30 million that they’d saved through using these schemes.

But Goldman Sachs didn’t feel like paying back the £30 million and fought tooth and nail in the courts against reimbursing the public purse. Time ticked on, and it wasn’t until 2010 that a judge threw out the claim from the Bank that their true employer was in the British Virgin Islands. Goldman Sachs’s debt to society now stood at the £30 million, plus £10 million in interest.

Goldman Sachs baulked at paying back what they owed, and so in late 2010, it’s been said in the press that they did what any self-respecting wannabe tax dodger does; they wined and dined Dave Harnett, HMRC’s top tax man. By the end of the brandy and cigars, it was all sorted. Goldman Sachs would pay back the original £30 mil and Dave would forget about the £10 million interest. Who needs it? You can’t buy many books, nurses or school meals with it anyway.

As the secret ‘sweetheart’ deal came to light, it all got a bit embarrassing in the press and in parliament. Dave Hartnett suggested to a Select Committee that it was a junior official’s error because of a misinterpretation of the law. According to the Guardian this month, HMRC sources privately confirm that £10m of taxpayers’ money was thrown away because of a “technical mistake” by an unidentified official, junior to Hartnett, who misinterpreted the law.

As anyone who has had any dealings with HMRC will know, there are procedures, policies and forms of many, many pages that must be filled in, in the right order and by the right date. We can’t buy Dave Hartnett a couple of cocktails and he’ll look the other way when it comes to our tax returns or National Insurance contributions.

This is at the heart of our legal action. We are saying that if was a genuine mistake, then it can be rectified and the money paid back. And being the reasonable people that we are, we have given them a couple of weeks to do so. If not though, we will see them in court, as we believe that this handshake agreement is unlawful because, reportedly, Dave didn’t follow HMRC’s own procedures. So if it’s not quashed, Dave’s dodgy deal could land him in the dock.

A year of #ukuncut

Posted on Thu 27th Oct 2011, 7:59pm
This blog is available in German, French and Spanish thanks to the good people at Tlaxcala

On October 27th 2010, just one week after George Osborne announced the deepest cuts to public services since the 1920s, 70 people ran along Oxford Street, entered Vodafone’s flagship store and sat down. Vodafone had dodged £6 billion of tax, so we shut down their flagship store. UK Uncut had been born.


We started as an idea and a hashtag; they both went viral. Just three days later, on October 30th, and thirty Vodafone stores had been closed around the country. One week later the ‘Big Society Revenue and Customs’ was launched – if the government weren’t going to make tax avoiders pay, we were. Philip Green’s tax avoiding empire was added to our list of targets and in London we shut down his biggest store. In Bury St Edmunds Alex and his Mum lay down in a Vodafone doorway, forcing it to close. That day 23 different towns and cities came out in protest. Two weeks later, on ‘Pay-Day’, there were 55 protests on high streets up and down the country. In Brighton activists dressed as Santa glued themselves inside BHS, London’s flag-ship Topshop store hosted an activist ‘sport-day’ with egg and spoon races, football and star jumps. In Liverpool a fifteen year-old girl organised an action and shut down a Topshop, before running home to revise for her GCSE the next morning. On January 30th we mobilised again, adding Boots and Tesco to our list of tax dodging targets, on the day before tax return deadline, up to 30 protests took place around the country. In the space of a couple of months, we had become a national movement.

February saw the start of the second stage of our campaign. We turned our attention to the banks. And ‘Uncut’ went global. On February 26th UK Uncut and the newly formed US Uncutbailed-in’ to the bailed-out banks. Over 100 actions took place, from London and Dundee to New York and Honolulu. In the UK, we set up crèches, laundries, school class rooms, libraries, homeless shelters, drama club, walk-in clinics, youth centre, job centres, and leisure centres in banks across the country. We had a simple message: it’s their crisis, they should pay for it.

Things didn’t slow down in March. On the 26th we joined the 500,000 other people marching through central London, demanding an alternative to cuts and austerity. UK Uncut groups from all over the country came together to transform Oxford Street, banks and shops were occupied and turned into libraries and theatres, we had Shakespeare at BHS with Sam and Anthony West, and an open air comedy gig with Josie Long and Mark Thomas performing. Hundreds of us then moved together to occupy the iconic Fortnum and Masons; iconic not just as the Queen’s grocery, but as a tax dodger. Hundreds of people took a stand against the government cuts and corporate tax avoidance. 145 of us were arrested and charged at a protest described by the senior police officer on the scene as ‘sensible and non-violent’. 30 of our number are still on trial. In the press and in Parliament we took one hell of a beating. But from difficult times, amazing new things emerged. The support and solidarity we have received has been inspiring, from groups and individuals, NGOs and trade unions, from Mums Uncut and Art Uncut.


And in May we bounced back! Once again we occupied banks across the country to perform an ‘Emergency Operation’ to save our NHS from government cuts. Activists dressed in scrubs and armed with fake blood and bandages set up ‘operating theatres’ inside branches of the four major banks. Uncut continued to go global, with Portugal and Canada Uncut holding their first actions. In April US Uncut staged hundreds of occupations of tax-dodging corporations from Hawaii to New Hampshire across a four-day period.

In June we supported the workers striking for the alternative, the Big Society Breakfast took solidarity-tea to the picket lines to show that ‘we are all in it together’. 700,000 were on strike that day; millions more are due out in November.

And on October 9th we took part in the biggest single act of mass civil disobedience in this country for years. Over two thousand people came to the heart of London from all over the country to occupy Westminster Bridge in a last stand for the NHS. We were entertained in the autumn sunshine by our clown doctors, and joined together with healthcare workers, patients, trade unionists and concerned citizens. We came to block the bridge and block the bill. We left empowered and inspired by the people willing to stand up for what’s right. The end of that action saw the first general assembly which would become Occupy London, still camped bravely outside St Paul’s.


What a year it has been. Every person who has been a part of UK Uncut should feel proud of what they have done, and empowered to do more. In one year we have come so far. From a hashtag and an idea, we have become a national and international network of people taking action.

UK Uncut is made up of the people who take part in actions. We are you. We are mums and pensioners, trade unionists and students, private sector employees and the unemployed, the disabled and school children. We are ordinary people standing up (or sitting-in) for what we believe, and for the change we want to see.

Occasionally people ask us what we’ve achieved and what we hope to achieve as UK Uncut. When they do, think of the inspiring, creative direct actions we’ve taken together, of the networks of friends and activists we’ve forged, and the debate we’ve lit about the genuine alternatives to these unnecessary cuts. We have had thousands of inches of coverage for our concerns in the national press, we got tax avoidance onto prime time television, we have helped shape the debate and pushed tax avoidance way up the political agenda. The Queen's lawyers said we had it right, HMRC ran training sessions on us and PR experts discussed how to deal with being targeted by UK Uncut. Bundles of public figures have come out in support of us, whilst Boris Johnson and Theresa May resorted to smears.

Think also of the hard won political victories which will, slowly but surely, bring about real political change. We have had MPs standing up for us in Parliament, signing early day motions and attempting to introduce tax reform. Our campaigning prompted the National Audit Office and the Treasury Select Committee to investigate dodgy tax dealings, investigations which now see Dave Hartnett up against the ropes and are forcing Revenue and Customs to re-think how they deal with corporate tax avoiders.


We still have a long way to go, a lot we can learn, and we will keep going together.

See you on the high streets!

Press release: Police block entrance to HMRC as UK Uncut and Occupy London demand resignation of boss Hartnett; Vince Cable heckled

Posted on Mon 24th Oct 2011, 3:32pm
POLICE BLOCK ENTRANCE TO HMRC AS UK UNCUT AND OCCUPY LONDON DEMAND RESIGNATION OF BOSS HARTNETT; VINCE CABLE HECKLED

For immediate release
Tel: 07415063231 / Email: ukuncut@gmail.com
Photos available at https://www.dropbox.com/gallery/15927156/1/Hartnett?h=65a8d7#/


Campers at Occupy London and activists from direct action group UK Uncut joined forces to descend upon the head office of Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs (HMRC) this afternoon to demand the resignation of HMRC boss Dave Hartnett [1].

Protesters- outraged at Hartnett's role in approving secret sweetheart deals to let mega-rich corporations off billions in tax- were prevented from reaching Hartnett's office by a heavy police presence. Minor scuffles ensued as police lined the main entrance to the building.

Later, Business Secretary Vince Cable happened to walk past the protest. He was followed to the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills with protesters demanding the sacking of Hartnett.

Hartnett was, last week, again dragged in front of parliament's Public Accounts Commitee to answer questions on dodgy deals with Vodafone and Goldman Sachs that cost the taxpayer up to £6bn and £10m respectively [2]. MPs on the committee accused Hartnett of abusing his position to "cover up his own mistakes".

A survey last year found that Hartnett was Whitehall's most 'wined and dined' civil servant, treated by corporations 107 times in 3 years to top a survey of 172 senior civil servants [3]. Tory MPs and commentators from across the political spectrum have joined the call for Hartnett to resign [4] [5] [6].

Occupy London supporter Kyshia Davey said: "HMRC has just announced it will be going after 146,000 pensioners to demand hundreds of pounds from them following a tax code cock-up. Meanwhile, its boss is striking secret deals with opulent corporations to let them off billions of pounds in tax. Hartnett is fatally undermining public confidence in the UK's tax system at a time of austerity and he must resign immediately."

UK Uncut activist Sam Gilbert added: "Whilst 25,000 rank-and-file staff at HMRC have been fired, leaving the organisation almost incapable of functioning, Hartnett has been carving out a career as the most 'wined and dined' civil servant in Whitehall. The money from Vodafone's £6bn tax dodge alone could have prevented all of the cuts in public services over the past year."

[1] http://www.ukuncut.org.uk/blog/time-to-resign
[2] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/8832473/Hartnett-pledges-to-answer-questions-on-odd-tax-deals.html
[3] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/politics/7833886/Whitehalls-most-wined-and-dined-civil-servant-is-HMRCs-Dave-Hartnett.html
[4] http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/oct/23/tax-avoidance-goldman-dave-hartnett?CMP=twt_iph
[5] http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-2051131/The-man-taxes-belief-fair-play.html?ito
[6] http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/oct/23/tax-dodging-goldman-sachs-greece?newsfeed=true

Displaying posts 163 - 165 of 279 in total

Latest posts

Support from GMB, Compass and War on Want
Sat 8th Oct 2011, 10:32am
Guest post: Why I Will Be Helping to Block The Bridge on Sunday
Thu 6th Oct 2011, 4:03pm
A message of support from Len McCluskey
Thu 6th Oct 2011, 3:44pm
A message of support from Mark Serwotka
Wed 5th Oct 2011, 5:48pm
Join the Clown Doctors on the Bridge
Wed 5th Oct 2011, 5:22pm
Got a few quid spare? Help transform Westminster Bridge!
Tue 4th Oct 2011, 11:22am
A message of support from George Monbiot
Tue 4th Oct 2011, 10:23am
Guest post: What "Any Qualified Provider" means for the NHS
Mon 3rd Oct 2011, 3:34pm
Block the Bridge, Block the Bill legal tips
Mon 3rd Oct 2011, 10:40am
Raise £1000 for the Brighton 9
Tue 27th Sep 2011, 11:28am
Displaying posts 171 - 180 of 279 in total